The Case Against Torture In this short documentary, a former defense lawyer for prisoners at Guantánamo Bay argues against the C.I.A.’s use of torture. ... is that the “absolutist” objections to torture are the only ones that should be appealed to in explaining why it’s wrong. Torture has been used for hundreds of years as ab effective, if not cruel way of extracting information from a prisoner. Assignment: persuasive essay What key points does the author use to argue the thesis? Anti-torture voices have been left sounding defensive, insecure, incoherent. Arguments against Torture. Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy - What is torture? … But surely the rule should be, don't torture except in extreme circumstances. Accompanying the moral arguments against torture, there must be legal procedures to ensure that the perpetrators of torture are brought to justice. Torture is not an effective method for national security. Antonio Taguba A retired major general in the U.S. Army, Antonio Taguba authored the document that became known as the “Taguba Report,” which exposed abuse at … What key points does the author use to argue the thesis? Torture corrupts and degrades the torturers. Human Rights First, along with dozens of interrogators, intelligence professionals, retired generals, and admirals, know that torture is ineffective at gaining actionable intelligence. CJ Werleman talks to Samira al-Houry, an activist who was assaulted and raped in a Houthi prison. Houthi supporters protest in front of the USembassy in Sanaa in January 2021. Answer Save. In “The Case Against Torture,” author and professor Alisa Soloman enumerates the reasons torture should never be practiced or justified in a civil society.. Click on the link to view the essay: “The Case Against Torture” by Alisa Soloman As you read, look for the following: What is the author’s thesis? Indeed, some countries are still using the capital punishment to convict criminals, show the severity of the population, and fear the criminals. ON TORTURE Naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Whereas some are convinced that torture is the only way to get information out of terrorist who are threatening to put thousands of innocent lives in danger. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg talked with Georgetown Law … This subsequently means that torture isn’t an effective means to get information. In addition, torture that is officially approved at least once tends to become a regular practice. So, even from a utilitarian point of view, a ban on torture may be justified. When it comes to the topic of torture, some of us will readily agree that torture is necessary when dealing with terrorists. Torture in the modern world is a relic of the distant past. Interrogation techniques that respect human rights have a proven track record of success at getting information out of terrorism suspects. much support for torture interrogation of terrorists has emerged in the public forum, largely based on the “ticking bomb” scenario. Torture … Thus the capital punishment is appropriate for several reasons: it's deterrent, it's cost-effective; and finally, it addresses heinous crimes. Do you agree or disagree with him? The use of torture by individuals, groups, and authorities has been going on from ancient times until today. Arguments against TORTURE? transcript. (Brennan Linsley/AP) By Chris Freind Monday, 13 February 2017 02:29 PM Current | Bio | Archive. 8.3: “The Case Against Torture,” by Alisa Soloman Last updated; Save as PDF Page ID 5409; No headers. According to Michael Levin’s article, “The Case for Torture,” his view on torture is that there are many situations in which torture would be against the law but would be obligatory for someone’s conscious. 880 Words 4 Pages. Arguments Against Torture 631 Words | 3 Pages. Is the evidence obtained by torture credible? Tel. Evidence suggests that attitudes toward torture practices have changed since the military commissions speech, perhaps indicating that Bush’s arguments for the morality of torture were successful.