Garrett’s critique of Uncle Sam’s wide-reaching international influence famously begins with the words “US Forces give the nod, it’s a setback for your country.”. Jesus, where’s a bucket! Once he joined a big party he realised that one man still can’t change much. I see quoted ‘Only the impotent are pure’ – but I don’t care if Gough ( one of my great Aussie heroes) said it. This great, beloved song is about the environmental evils committed by big business. The article sums up beautifully that Garret himself, eventually showed that everything his band stood for was bollocks. The problem is that Pete entered politics and then proceeded to do the exact opposite of everything he ‘believed’ in, and sang about. And when Mick entered parliament…? Peter had good intentions but like many with good intentions including people like Bob Brown they get side tracked or railroaded or they go too far the other way. No way would I be going to any of his concerts. You can read a review of Garrett’s autobiography ‘Big Blue Sky’ by Guy Rundle here: Thanks Raymond, I enjoyed that review. Let’s give it back. How f**king funny was the St KIlda song at the start of the AFL Footy Show. This protects creators from their work being used in a derogatory way that may negatively impact on their character or reputation.”. Peter Garrett #4890 . Yep Garret tried working both sides of the fence & found that… Yep; Politicians are a bunch sleazebags. He was just positing that we “imagine” no possessions. Nice post Peeb. You’d think…or at least hope, that in a society where voting is compulsory people would have a better understanding of the political system. Aussies use to celebrate the battler because we didnt allow others to bullshit us to think what they thought.So if you are not perfect, have a think before you judge other. If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device. Nice beat, but. Got more say than people. Or my Tony Abbott. that show last night disgraced everything about rugby league - from the game itself to the people that follow it. I am inclined to agree. And here’s the nuance because you seem to have missed is: that does not mean he backtracked on his beliefs. Copy link. You can’t realise that to make some progress towards your goals you may have to negotiate and compromise. Hmm, lots of OILS fans here who don’t like yr persuasive truth Luke. Uranium companies Stu thank you for such an excellent defence of Peter Garrett. And long live the mighty oils. Photo downloads. I guess a narky piece of writing about the most important thing to happen on the Australian music scene this year was too good a hook…. Lucky you. John Lydon, it turns out, was not the antichrist. Peter Garrett’s essay in ‘Upturn: A better normal’, edited by Tanya Plibersek, rightly castigates the federal government’s continuing support for fossil fuels and its failure to implement effective climate mitigation policies. With all the moral integrity of an ASIO dossier. As environment minister please elucidate how Garrett could have changed his decision based on departmental advice, public submissions and EPBC legislation. How naïve is it to believe that pragmatism isn’t going to play a part in a politicians life. And that’s no way to rock out. Unfortunately there are no concert dates for Peter Garrett scheduled in 2021. Wake up, they sold out, great arrangements. The first couple of pages reveal so much about the worry and the turmoil that he went through in making those decisions and also his decision to stay in politics for as long as he did. By Peter Garrett MP. Peter Garrett Their current Great Circle world tour, their first in 15 years, has taken them across the US. Yep, MO come across as just another form of white paternalistic colonial bullshit, Wake up Australia, this country is operating on covert apatheid. The political system is imperfect, compromise is certain, progress slow, and everyone gets dragged through the mud. Note: Your email address is included with the abuse report. Perhaps he has a change of heart. Peter Garrett (Arts Minister) presenting the Don Banks Music Award 2010 With Marcus Holden at Mosman Library 2012 National Folk Festival The Larrikins in the 1970s. Garrettattained his primary education in Pymble Sydney, at a school called `Gordon West Public School.’ He was focused on his education and later, he joined `Barker College’ and `Australian National University’ for higher learning. I’m sure all those having a whine have written heaps of catchy, meaningful songs about social justice and are campaigning tirelessly for equality. precolonial Aboriginal society included wife abduction, infanticide, ritual spearing and the non-existence of any Australian national political entity. But he didn’t enact any change. toggle quoted message Show quoted text. Lived In Fort Lauderdale FL, Boca Raton FL, Delray Beach FL, Easton PA. Related To Garrett Vansiclen, Frances Vansiclen. Wow, arent people allowed to explore options without the anally fixated among us demanding some sort of religious conviction….the facts change. It will be interesting and perhaps enlightening. Shortly after Taber burns his foot and does his Peter Garrett impersonation, McMurphy gets into a fight with the “black boys”; Chief Bromden gets involved, and they are both taken “upstairs” for a 10,000-volt crown of thorns. (snigger). He is an actor and producer, known for The Adventures of Ford Fairlane (1990), Blue Jasmine (2013) and A Star Is Born (2018). Once were warriors. Member for Kingsford Smith. In this lively introduction, Peter Garrett draws upon research carried out over recent decades in order to discuss such attitudes and the implications they have for our use of language, for social advantage or discrimination, and for social identity. I think it is a mistake to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Luke – be quiet. Utter nonsense. he would always have been a more effective advocate outside the system than within. (I’ll be paying). And as for a subsequent claim on another site which shared the Daily Review piece that Peter “literally signed over Aboriginal land to uranium companies “. Can’t believe the writer waited until the band got back together to take ‘action’ on these very important issues. He did emphasise in song the need to have both passion and power, and to his undying credit he said, and accepted the difficult parameters involved, that he would play a role in a Government that did not necessarily accord with every view he felt comfortable with. But again: the song’s got to go from the set list, right? What self serving bollocks. Good analogy, Susan. Oh, no. Well said. I have some advice for you – !. Perhaps the line was edited from something a little less catchy: “It’s better to die on your feet than to live on your knees, unless entering a period of discussions committed in good faith between multiple parties whereby decisions can be reached and compromises made to achieve a multi-faceted outcome representing a myriad of political and economic impulses, acknowledging the many interests – vested and otherwise – entrenched in a modern mainstream political machine”. I was gonna buy a ticket for the Nambour concert in October. He didnt’ just fawn over Obama and expanded bases here, he bloody apologized to obama for the US Forces song. Laurie Oakes said he made his views very clear in the party room but majority rules. Photos on this page are available for download but the moral rights of the creator should be observed including “… the right of integrity of authorship. twas ever thus in the history of world affairs. Regardless you will obviouly be down the pub having few beers with Luke whilst the rest of us are watching some of the most powerful music of a generation. I doubt that the author of this article has read it. ‘Cowboys are square’. Garrett's father, a corporate executive, also named Peter, died of an illness when the budding musician was still in school. The art is its own thing and no amount of political chicanery will ever alter its power. THIS ARTICLE WAS PAID FOR WITH THE SUPPORT OF DAILY REVIEW READERS. Now simply embarrassing IF you've ever stolen a towel from a hotel, beware, technology is catching up with you. The iconic The Power the Passion poses the same question many of Garrett’s fans came to ask: “What do you believe, what do you believe?” Its chorus includes the line “Sometimes you’ve got to take the hardest line” and the final verse concludes with “It’s better to die on your feet than to live on your knees”. He needs to address these issues or its a farce. Click on thumbnail (below) to see photo then save to your computer then right-mouse click (PC) or CTRL click (MAC) to save I was in my last years of school when I first heard his music and I thought it was daft then too. Iwould be surprised if their principles have changed. Sadly he got wound up in the Labor machine and many of its platforms. Shadow Parliamentary Secretary for Reconciliation and the Arts. Jack: *nods* Lawson: But I’m talking of slow-dancing. Hirsty and Jim M were really the ideological engine room. Required fields are marked *. There are 100+ professionals named "Pete Garrett", who use LinkedIn to exchange information, ideas, and opportunities. Good luck to him and the crew, I wish them well. My drunen mate thinking he's the front man of Midnight Oil. BOOM, respectfully places mic back in mic stand. Get Hulu. Peter lived in 1860, at address, Illinois. You just do not get it. The Oils songs are still relevant as not too much progress has been made on many indigenous australians issues, but on the other hand they also need to be part of the solution. I wish him well. Imagine Mick Jagger wrote a kick arse rock song about the evils of uranium mining. The band who portrayed themselves as anti-establidhment, hell raisers by her Satanic majesty’s request? In 2011 he praised a speech by Barack Obama on expanded American military presence and said greater American participation in our region can only be a good thing, citing national security issues and terrorism as core reasons for the aboutface. Go hard, Luke! Once he saw that ALP party politics was inimical to his principles,it was time to pull out. Videos you watch may be added to the TV's watch history and influence TV recommendations. John Lennon did actually have possessions, quite a few in fact. They believe he is still cashing in on their culture despite betraying them. 53 years and counting, U.K. Oils fan. I think you do a terrible disservice. This hot-blooded song about an anti-establishmentarian standing up for the “true country” by rejecting contemporary politics and following “in the steps of our ancestry” includes the following lyrics: Mining companies, pastoral companies Impersonation of doctors is a modern phenomenon that grew out of Western medicine’s drive towards professionalism. That’s arrogant,rationalising bulldust. The projects he signed off on were approved before he came to the job an to renege on them would’ve had the government in court. Good for him. In the privacy of the party room he cast his vote on various issues. tho a bloody great performer. This is what too much Midnight Oil does to older brains. It’s fair to argue that his best wasn’t good enough, or that (as it turns out) a career singing political songs wasn’t the ideal preparation for … tho a f**kin great performer. Military force by the United States saved the world from the Nazis, the domination of imperial japan, the domination of Europe by the Soviet Union and the US has been Australia’s insurance against any enemy aggression towards Australia for many decades – the alternative would be Australia spending four or five times what it does on defence (probably at the expense of other programs, including Aboriginal welfare). Peter Garrett is not a hypocrite or sellout, he had been in politics and activism for a long time and realised unless you join Labour or Liberal you never get to change anything. Cancel Report Obviously a youngster like this Luke. As for ” good on him for havin a go” – don”t come the raw prawn !! But if you think his political career has irreparably tarnished his songs, you’ve got it the wrong way around. Whatever your views on Garrett himself, you can’t deny that Midnight Oil are greater than the sum of their parts. How could he (or we) possibly rock along to it now? Flight captain Peter Chilvers, 34, who was jailed for 18-months for driving his fiancee to stab their 23-month-old son to death after psychological torment is released from prison after five months. Here it is again: Channel 9 Footy Show 2011 - New Year - New Ad - Same Crap, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRMVTPKbzcQ, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tyVxoeW3LFI, (You must log in or sign up to reply here. As therapeutic as a balmy night on a Cabo beach. As for relevance with regard to his songs, they have relevance today, surprisingly so when we look at the world today. There are 100+ professionals named "Peter Garrett", who use LinkedIn to exchange information, ideas, and opportunities. This followed revelations that a bribe the singer said he was offered by Clubs NSW in the form of an envelope stuffed full of cash actually never happened. I guess, to cite the Stones, as you have Luke – ‘ I know it’s only rock ‘n’ roll but I like it’. Check it out.). Garrett isn’t perfect, but I’m with most of the contributors here Luke. Make up your own mind. Fuck me! In front of packed out stadiums, he belted out his anti-uranium song once more. Surely MO and PG are something to be celebrated by Aussies? He’s a hypocrite and a sellout full stop. Give back all monies made from your protest / idealism music that you scammed from us 20 yrs ago , 2. A good anthemic, beer barn sorta band with a fun lead singer. Hello, Sign in. To avoid this, cancel and sign in to YouTube on your computer. Mick got rich, got married, got resorts….musicians aren’t gurus, give it a rest! ENVIRONMENT Minister Peter Garrett and Liberal leader Malcolm Turnbull, the two richest members of Parliament, share a fondness for trees and much else. My Order of the Wattle. Midnight Oil frontman Peter Garrett leapt at the chance to pick five 'songs of reckoning' when Zan Rowe gave him the topic for his episode of Take 5 on Double J. Certainly nothing he would have achieved with a small minority party. Are you sure you wish to delete this message from the message archives of … With all the moral integrity of a Rex Connor dossier. Chris o'donnell net worth. Now we are seeing Turnbull doing the same, but at least he got to be PM. Find information on all of Peter Garrett’s upcoming concerts, tour dates and ticket information for 2021-2022. Watching the afl show, compare how their players talk to how ours do.... - I don't mind Voss but the same gag can go too far. As Stu points out, did you call Garret and ask how he voted on the Caucus? He has been married to Valerie … Play the ball, not the man. Is there something wrong with this picture? This article really is facile. If that was a pre-requisite for being in Labor, surely he should have quit the party and continued on as an Independent or rejoined the greens. Hi Tim, The oils wont need you there, tickets will sell out regardless if you come or not. Now imagine you make it to the door but instead of it being locked your … Peter Garrett Vansiclen, 43. Depends if you’re talking about me…or him. And check out the support bands for the tour…including the young Indigenous band Irrunytju , signed up after Peter Garrett saw them while taking part and advising them in a workshop at the Bush Bands Bash in Alice last year…they, Dan Sultan, and other proud Indigenous people don’t seem to have a problem. Essentially I’ve always seen him as a spotlight-seeking egotist. Let’s see what Peter has to say for himself. After this, he pursued a degree i… (See you at the pub, Pammy. Many of these issues are addressed by Garrett in his autobiography, which I recommend. A legal approach to the decline and fall of the United States, Sleaford Mods ‘All That Glue’ review: a necessary album for fans and newcomers alike, ‘The Shifting Landscape’ review: Western Victoria crime novel showcases joy in storytelling, How did we get here? Lot’s of good left wing political lyrics as well. Good at singing someone else’s tune. Up the Oils! Right onnot being a nice person is not in the same cintext as selling out indigenous peoples land rights to uranium mines, especially when PG was so anti uranium mining, nit the same as silly live songs is it????? Well said Luke. Eddie Garrett… At least Screaming Lord Sutch stood by his principles. At the end of the day, the bloke gave the best years of his life to conservation, social justice and the Arts. Peter Garrett remembers Brisbane's Cloudland clearly and its loss is something he still feels to this day. Two facts outshine this over simplification of some of the many complexities of politics that are clearly difficult to fathom. If he wanted to change things politically, why didn’t he join the Greens, and thus stick by his principles, he had the choice? This is such a poorly argued piece. Peter Garrett #4904 . As a Tasmanian, I deplored what he did in not supporting Bob Brown, and in signing agreement to uranium mines, it was abjectand all you whimps saying oh, people change, sure, but change back with any conviction at all? Petey is much more intelligent than that. Collected companies Opinions are one thing, but so many statements by the author are simply untrue – they are “alternative facts” (as D.Trump would say). That’s arrogant,rationalising bullshit. So principles not a strong point. Fair enough. That Garrett would know that in advance and do it anyway speaks volumes. Pete just sang them. Listen to the opening chorus of the Dead Heart, and hear how the harmonies of the band make such a great lyrical counterpoint to the harsh gravel of Garrett, whose voice is so instantly recognizable and unique. Garrett had the opportunity when he got elected to speak his mind. Are you Googling Peter Garrett dance impersonations? :lol::lol::lol:With the exception of Sam Newman's Peter Garrett impersonation, the other skits were mildly humourous up until the St Kilda parody (which was the last one). Last week Midnight Oil announced its first world tour in 15 years. No? Also known as Peter G Vansicien, Van Siclen Peter Garrett. As of February 2021, Chris O'Donnell has an estimated net worth of $15 million.He has appeared in various super hit films, and his films have done pretty well on box office. Lyrics about Indigenous land rights in the iconic Beds are Burning – possibly the band’s most famous song – include: The time has come [The TRUST report of this move, visible at liverail 1609p (charlwoodhouse.co.uk), shows some erroneous manual reporting: a departure time from Etches Park listed between the arrival and departure times at Derby station (entered a few minutes after it set off, and obviously a guess), and a "train terminated" entry for Derby while it was between Syston North and East (entered after the train … In defence of Garret, Bill Clinton would argue: that’s the economy, stupid! Peter Garrett 2006 Sorry Day Speech. I saw others try that and achieve nothing. I’m the cute one! See you at the concert. Whether or not his convictions now remain identical to those he held 30 years ago is, furthermore, entirely irrelevant – and what would Buckmaster know of Garrett’s principles anyway? But as pointed out by the fans, Horst wrote all the strong stuff. Midnight Oil may be coming back, but the power and the passion was sacrificed long ago. Then it was time for him to say – ” Naaah, I’m outa here. What I am saying is that this article overlooks the fact that this is a band, not one person, a band that incorporates different voices into a whole. He’d have had a lot more impact and potentially the balance of power and thats a *VERY* strong position to negotiate positive change. Will Midnight Oil’s comeback tour include renditions of The Dead Heart? Christopher O'Donnell was born on June 26, 1970, in Winnetka, Illinois. Petey had plenty of time, in 2 terms in govt, to see that his ‘supposed’ principles were gonna be severely compromised. View the profiles of people named Peter Garrett on Facebook. Facebook gives people the power to … Problem is, though, that the result might be my Peter Garrett impersonation. Or a bizarre “mis-memory” as he has described it. I disagree with Guy when he says that no-one went to an Oils concert for the harmonies. Songs can’t live on outside the author? Fast forward three decades later and, despite remaining an outspoken anti-uranium activist (also once a candidate for the Nuclear Disarmament Party) Peter Garrett oversaw expansion of the uranium industry, including approving two mines in South Australia. Just another example of confected outrage and tall poppy syndrome which seems so prevalent in society. | February 21, 2017 |. He had to alter positions for the sake of tbe Party. Garrett explained how Peter thought that he had had a mate once named Charlotte, but it was later determined that she had a gift that enabled her to create mating bonds and it wasn't until she was killed during one of the battles did Peter come to his senses and … Peter Garrett is a long-time advocate and campaigner on a range of local and global issues. In any case the band is one of the greats…. Pammy, whether you love or hate what Peter Garrett has done since the Oils the one thing that can be said is that at least he got off of his backside and had a go at changing the world, most other rockers dont have what it takes to even give it a go. GenY too! He fucked up with a few political decisions but any one who follows the machine that is factional ALP politics would say that to step out of the boundaries is political suicide. But he didn’t abandon principles. So, maybe restricting me to James Bloody Squire might be the best outcome after all. Peter Garrett #4890 . arts and entertainment news, reviews and commentary. Cute, or pathetic. No “blunting” there! That might sound a bit odd coming from Garrett, given what we now know of his political style. And Luke you look like a smug bastard. Many environmental activists have claimed Garrett acted precisely in the interests of companies taking what they want, from his support of the Tasmanian logging industry to the $1 billion dredging of Port Phillip Bay. Secret weapon: Peter Garrett (pictured in 2006 with wife Doris 2nd from left) enlisted his daughters Emily (left), May and Grace (right) as backup singers for … Delivered at First Fleet Park, Circular Quay West, Sydney. It belongs to them Cancel Report × Close Verify Delete. Your email address will not be published. Perhaps Malcolm didn't warm to Fellsy courting the left before the 2007 election using his (then) arts links at Opera Australia to woo Peter Garrett. On Fri, 12 Jun 2020, 18:54 Stuart Moore, wrote: Just seen 2 Colas 70s on Railcam in Peterborough heading for Whitemoor. The rocker himself gave his personal approval, with a contract announcing uranium mine expansion bearing his signature. Jackie Lambie, Pauline Hanson, Nick Xenophon – all sticking to their guns and being major influencers in our parliament. Andrew Dice Clay was born on September 29, 1957 in Brooklyn, New York, USA as Andrew Clay Silverstein. View the profiles of professionals named "Peter Garrett" on LinkedIn. So where were all you idealists when PG put his dick on the brick and gave it a go in the snakepit? This same judgmental negative shit has seen us critisise war heroes, driven by out of touch journalist sitting from a distant office. Problem is, though, that the result might be my Peter Garrett impersonation. Sure he voted along party lines as any good well healed newbie should. I wonder if people consider that Peter Garrett as an intelligent and self aware person, went into politics fully expecting this kind of antipathy and backlash. After all, the two have a bit in common. At some point the songs of our youth become product… behind car commercials, performed on tours by a band with the corporate name of the band with some, or maybe even only one, original member. Arguably one of your finest exports? 2: The Oils rock. In face, Garrett, as a songwriter, comes in at a distant third after Hirst and Mogine, the group’s principle songsmiths. He was a star candidate with enough pull that the party couldn’t have contained him and if he’d taken the approach from day one of speaking his mind as he did in his songs, he would have easily been able to shift party policy, even if only a little bit. Nah, crap. In June 2015, Midnight Oil frontman Peter Garrett walked on stage at Barunga Festival in the Northern Territory to join two of his contemporaries, Paul Kelly and Dr G. Yunupingu. Here, she and her colleagues bring us often trenchant accounts of the Hawke ascendancy from sources ranging from John Howard and Bill Kelty to John Eales, Peter Garrett, Max Gillies, Meredith Burgmann, Blanche d’Alpuget, Dennis Richardson and Susan Ryan (who at times in the archival footage is the only woman, surrounded by a mass of hefty Labor blokes, a tight smile on her lips). ... Peter Garrett; Smallpox; Kontributor teratas. One of Gough’s less worthy, blustering moments. To go back to performing those old polemical songs once more, as if nothing has occurred over the last decade and a half that might in some way dint their impact, is a truly weird and deflating state of affairs. And Peter Garrett, when faced with the trade-offs and compromises that serve as impediments to positive change in the real world, did his best. (Do love your Billy Childish, though. A trite article for reasons well covered by contributors below e.g Dogs Breakfast. (The element, not the band). he would always have been a more effective advocate outside the system thanm within. posted 2008-Nov-3, 10:23 pm AEST ref: whrl.pl/RbFLLz. And sometimes songs are best expressed by vocalists who don’t have mainstream pop voices. What’s your point, Russ? But to try and rekindle the old stuff from a different era will be an interesting expose on strolling down money pit lane. Look, Midnight Oils music was perfectly fine in the eighties. Peter Garrett #5651 . Luke is using the “paint by numbers” approach used by the LNP while they were in Opposition in the House of Reps. I for one am looking forward to hearing him sing US Forces and Blue Sky Mine. Did you even try…? Quoting lyrics as a critique of a fully informed government policy is simply lazy. Impersonation of doctors is a modern phenomenon that grew out of Western medicine’s drive towards professionalism. So he tried to take the next step and got reined in. The Oils cleaned up! Oh, Zing, Starskier! L.U. Lawson: *blinks* Oh. I would have achieved nothing by staying schtumm and working within an oppressive unprincipled system. Hope this is not seen as a cheap shot, but hard not to ask whether you got lot of clicks for that one, Luke? As said by another, and E G Whitlam, only the impotent are pure. It is a sincere and well-written book,and lays bare many of the wounds and pain that he suffered in politics, but also highlights his achievements. Info. Garrett is/was the Oils frontman..who cares who wrote the material..he sung the songs and achieved the fame that got him elected; what he demonstrated with his political career,is that the Oils political activism was really just their schtick,born out of the 60’s/70’s hippy and environmentalist era. Despite the band claiming to have found new relevance in the Trump era, I can’t help but think Garrett’s evolution from long-term activist to politically expedient pragmatist is – or should have been – a one-way street. U2, notably. Thanks for your (and other readers’ comments) on Luke’s article. The level of sniping here is out of hand. Bulletin Latest Headlines direct to your inbox, © LeagueUnlimited | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer. Look what Peter Garrett gave up to enter politics and tell me how much money and adoration you would give up to try and do something constructive, not critical. Resign your ministership and crawl into a hole so deep that you never again emerge. Give me a break.He didn’t “give anything a go”. Peter Garrett was born on 16th April 1953 in Wahroonga, New South Wales, Australia. But now, Luke, you bugger, you have me thinkin twice. I agree. Imagine his political career didn’t work out so well, so Jagger returned to the Stones. Categories. He wasn’t in charge, as far as I could see he got a hell of a shock when entered parliament and found out what a grubby business it was. Not that the Environment Minister, Peter Garrett, was actually in the Federal Court this week to spin the Port of Melbourne's fairytale on its planned dredging of Port Phillip Bay. I would have achieved nothing by staying schtumm. Unforgivable. While well known for their hard-driving rock, their creative output was actually incredibly diverse. 50% of something beats 100% of nothing, and only the impotent are pure. Knock off the Gough insults. Nicola Louise Roxon (born 1 April 1967) is a former Australian politician, who was a member of the House Representatives representing the seat of Gellibrand in Victoria for the Australian Labor Party from the 1998 federal election until her retirement in August …